Following is an enumeration of the science liens and conetnt questions raised 
by the external reviewers who reviewed this data set in October 2003.  In
some cases it is known that the liens have not been addressed.  In other
cases it was not possible for the personnel tasked with ingesting the data 
set to determine whether the liens were addressed to the likely satisfaction 
of the reviewers.

Note that the presentation by A. Vinas referenced below is also included
in the documentation for the data set (as "vinas_pepe.ppt").

-Anne Raugh, Small Bodies Node, 04 October 2005.
______________________________________________________________________________

o  Compare contents of ASCII and binary data file to ensure the conversion 
   did not alter the data values.  A known problem with time-of-flight values
   will be fixed.

o  Check and verify ion efficiencies.

o  Amend documentation to indicate the state of knowledge of electron 
   efficiencies.

o  Add to the M/Q bin description a section specifying which species fall 
   within each bin.

o  Add a discussion of the spacecraft potential problem, as far as it is 
   understood.

o  Move information in the calinfo.txt file into a more stable, permanent 
   location.  Some of the description currently contained in the DATA_SET 
   catalog file will be moved to the same document.

o  Fix the human-readable times in the data files (known software problem in 
   the conversion).

o  Check the information in the (new) calibration document, including the 
   errors identified by Vinas in his presentation slide "Issues of PEPE's
   Information Files":
     1. Instrumental and calibration parameters should be collected into 
        a single place for reference.
     2. Correct the description of the determination of phase space density
        to indicate that the energy factor in the equation is energy per 
        charge.
     3. Provide a description of the physically meaningful quantities that
        can be determined, with formulae and algorithms.
     4. The labels on Table 2 of the calibration file are incorrect - they
        are not detector efficiencies, they are solid angles.
     5. Provide an example of composition determination.

o  The dataset.cat file description of coordinate systems needs a minus 
   sign in front of the unit vectors.

o  dataset.cat
 - The text passages are not attributed.
 - There are numerous spelling and grammatical errors in the text.

o  pepe.cat
 - The text passages are not attributed.
 - There are numerous spelling and grammatical errors in the text.

o  pepe_ref.cat
 - The reference list is incomplete, and apparently some of the anticipated
   papers were never published, or were not written by the indicated authors,
   or never existed in the first place.

   References to non-existent papers have been removed.  Note that the
   "YOUNGETINPRESS" paper has yet to be published as of this writing 
   (October 2005).