DSIDS_0001 ========== ========== o Somewhere on this volume is a single file with the wrong DATA_SET_ID: "DS1-C-IDSP-3-RDR-BORRELLY-V1.0" [root] ====== aareadme.txt - line 13: What is this hyphen supposed to mean? - line 16: This list is meaningless to anyone not already intimately familiar with PDS volume requirements - line 18: "Processing" is misspelled. voldesc.cat - Is this the right VOLUME_SET_ID? Don't they typically end in "_XXXX"? - VOLUME_VERSION_ID is incorrect - "CDR" is not a valid MEDIUM_TYPE. - DESCRIPTION grammar is not great. - The instrument host and mission catalog file names are incorrect - The syntax in the CATALOG object list is inconsistent - There is no target catalog file mentioned. - There is a syntax error on line 35 (two quotes). catalog ======= There is no target catalog file present. ids_ds.cat - This file has DATA_SET_COLLECTION_MEMBER_FLG set to "Y", but there is no DATA_SET_COLLECTION catalog file in this directory. - The text in the DATA_SET_DESC field needs to be formatted according to standards (indented, no more than 72 characters wide, etc.). - Who is the author of this description? - line 32: Missing space around (apparent) full stop. - line 45: "approximately" is misspelled. - line 46: Multiple misspellings - line 66: "the" appears to be missing before "tunable" - "Software" section should be omitted if it in not applicable. ids_inst.cat - Who is the author of this text? - The INSTRUMENT_DESC text needs to be reformatted according the standards. - line 59: Why is the word "events" in quotes in this sentence? - line 85: The word "hardware" is misspelled. - line 104: PDS REFERENCE_KEY_IDS are not suitable substitutes for proper citations. - line 116: Why is the word "scan" in quotes? - line 121: Why is the word "burst" in quotes? - Henry, et al. (2000) is listed as a reference at the end of the text but is not included in the INSTRUMENT_REFERENCE_INFO object. ids_ref.cat - There is a syntax error (two quotes) on line 6. insthost.cat - This text does not even begin to follow the required format. - Who is the author of this text? - line 15: "in space" should be hyphenated. - line 41: The comma is unneccesary. - line 44: Why is the word "wings" in quotes? - line 61: The plural of "antenna" (in this sense) is "antennas". - line 73: This sentence changes tense in the middle. "Is" is incorrect. - line 82: This sentence changes tense in the middle. "Are" is incorrect. - line 85: "e.g." must always be followed by a comma. - line 110: Bad combination of tenses. "Have been" should be "had been". mission.cat - Who is the author of this text? - line 37: "an" should be "and". - line 122: There is some sort of typo involved with the string "4of", but it's not clear what. - line 124: The term "remote agent" is enigmatic and should be explained. - line 126: Bugs aren't corrected, they're removed or fixed. - line 149: "Elongate" should be "elongated". Also "smallest solar system body targeted" by what? - line 151: There is no period at the end of this apparent sentence. Is something else missing as well? - line 166: Why is Mars suddenly mentioned here? Prior to this point there is no indication that DS1 ever looked in the direction of Mars, yet here it is mentioned casually. - line 194: What the heck is "closesiptic"? - line 203: "An" appears to be missing before the word "instrument". - line 220: The number "8" should be spelled out as "eight". - line 231ff: This paragraph changes tense in the middle. Pick one. - line 236: "5" should be "five". - line 243: Indentation is wrong here (or more blank space is needed between lines), and the numerals should be spelled out. - line 265: "SEPpropelled" should have a hyphen in it. document ======== ids_integrated_report.lbl - SYNTAX ERRORS: line 46: Missing end quote - line 38: "JPEG" should be "JPG". - line 41: "CCITT/3" is not a valid encoding type. - line 60: "ADOBE-PDF-1.2" is not a valid encoding type. - Do we have copyright permission to republish this report? document/backgrnd ================= pws_call_approach_c.lbl - line 24: "JPEG" should be "JPG" - line 27: "CCITT/3" is not a valid ENCODING_TYPE. - Do we have copyright permission to republish this paper? data ==== psb1_01.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - The DESCRIPTION of the first column is empty. The column needs describing. - What kind of unit is "(rms)"? - The abbreviation for Hertz is incorrect wherever it appears. - Frequency and bandwidth for each column should be given as the value of the CENTER_FREQUENCY and BANDWIDTH keywords, not in a rather cryptic DESCRIPTION field. psr1_01.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - The DESCRIPTION of the first column is empty. The column needs describing. - What kind of unit is "(rms)"? - The abbreviation for decibel is incorrect wherever it appears, assuming the string is intended to mean decibel-microvolts. - The CHANNEL_13 column has a different UNIT than all the other channels. - Frequency and bandwidth for each column should be given as the value of the CENTER_FREQUENCY and BANDWIDTH keywords, not in a rather cryptic DESCRIPTION field. pwb*.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - DESCRIPTION for the TABLE object makes no sense. (The TABLE object is not a label, it is the data.) - COLUMN 1 DESCRIPTION: What's the "given frame"? - DESCRIPTION of the third column is empty. The column needs describing. - How many significant digits are there in these data? sb*.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - DESCRIPTION for the TABLE object makes no sense. (The TABLE object is not a label, it is the data.) - COLUMN 1 DESCRIPTION: What's the "given frame"? - DESCRIPTION of the third column is empty. The column needs describing. - Are there really 9 significant digits in these data? sb006.lbl - This file has the wrong DATA_SET_ID, and uses "IDSP" rather than "IDS" everywhere. scb1_01.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - The DESCRIPTION of the first column is empty. The column needs describing. - The abbreviation for Hertz is incorrect wherever it appears. - Frequency and bandwidth for each column should be given as the value of the CENTER_FREQUENCY and BANDWIDTH keywords, not in a rather cryptic DESCRIPTION field. - This file uses a different convention for indicating the square root then the psb and psr labels. All labels in this data set should use the same convention (either Hz**-.5 or Hz**(-1/2)). scr1_01.lbl - START_TIME and STOP_TIME end in 'Z'. This is almost certainly wrong. - The DESCRIPTION of the first column is empty. The column needs describing. - The abbreviation for decibel is incorrect wherever it appears, assuming the string is intended to mean decibel-picoTesla. - Frequency and bandwidth for each column should be given as the value of the CENTER_FREQUENCY and BANDWIDTH keywords, not in a rather cryptic DESCRIPTION field. index ===== indxinfo.txt - This file has nothing to do with this volume. It's an IHW info.txt file. index.lbl - THIS LABEL CONTAINS SYNTAX ERRORS: line 9: Missing closing quote line 23: "START_TYPE" should be "START_BYTE" - VOLUME_ID is not a valid VOLUME_ID. It is also not the VOLUME_ID as given in the voldesc.cat file for the volume. - The START_BYTE of the first column is incorrect - this column starts in byte 2, not byte 1. index.tab - This file does not have CR/LF delimiters. - This file lists data files, not label files. - The PRODUCT_ID and DATA_SET_ID entry for sb006.tab is incorrect because it uses the wrong instrument abbreviated, and the values were truncated to fit the field.