===============================================================================
EPOXI, Jul 2013, SAM:
  Resolved liens for the "DIF" EPOCh Earth and Mars V2.0 datasets that were 
  peer reviewed by SBN on 05 Mar 2013.  My comments regarding the resolution 
  of each lien start with the string ">> SAM:".
EPOXI, 29 Mar 2013, SAM:
  Resolved the following liens the following "DIF" Hartley2 datasets that were 
  peer reviewed by SBN on 05 Mar 2013.  My comments regarding the resolution of
  each lien start with the string ">> SAM:".
===============================================================================


DIF-C-MRI-5-EPOXI-HARTLEY2-PHOTOM-V1.0
=======================================
o  Typos submitted separately by M.Knight.  
>> SAM:  Done.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.  Copied the updated, commond
         catalog files to other datasets in lien resolution.  Also fixed
         a typo in one document, noted in carcich_typo_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted R.Chen.  See chen_email_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted M.Knight.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.

Result: Certified


DIF-C-HRIV-5-EPOXI-HARTLEY2-DECONV-V1.0
=======================================
o  Add information about the deconvolution algorithm to documentation (see
   Jian-Yang's presentation)
>> SAM:  Done.  Clarified text that directs user to Lindler, et al. (2013)
   before using the data products.  
o  Add some guidance about the differences between the images - so a user could
   tell which might be appropriate for various uses (see Jian-Yang's
   presentation)
>> SAM:  Done.  Enhanced the Limitations section of dataset.cat with text 
   provided by D.Lindler.
o  Replace null value of "-88.88" in deconv_image_parameters.tab with a flag
   value that is out of range, like "-999". Tony Farnham and Jian-Yang Li have
   already calculated the actual values.  If possible add them to the table
   rather than leaving them null.  Note in the label the origin of the values
   added.
>> SAM:  Done.  Pulled sub-s/c and sub-solar lons/lats from FITS headers and
   put in data labels and image parameter table.  The label for the image
   parameter table has always stated the source are keywords in the PDS data
   labels. 
o  In deconv_image_parameters.tab, column 33 definition of "partial saturated
   pixel" is not clear.
>> SAM:  Done.
o  The /DATA/ section is repeated in the AAREADME.TXT file.
>> SAM:  Done.
o  Typos to be submitted separately.
>> SAM:  Done. Fixed a typo in dataset.cat.  See li_typos_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  08 Mar:  Edited dif.cat per Jian-Yang's suggestions of page 13 of his 
         presentation.
>> SAM:  15 Mar:  Replaced latest catalogs.  See See knight_typos_resolved.txt.
         Also in dataset.cat & ref.cat, changed LINDLERETAL2012 and KELLEYETAL2012 
         to ...2013 and updated pub dates. 
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted R.Chen.  See chen_email_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted M.Knight.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.

Result: Certified


DIF-C-HRII-3/4-EPOXI-HARTLEY2-V2.0
==================================
o  In the documentation, emphasize which temperatures are critical for
   calibration (Mike DiSanti and Lori Feaga will work the details).
>> SAM:  Done.  Added details provided by L.Feaga to the EPOXI FITS keywords
         document, EPOXI SIS, and dataset.cat for this dataset.
o  Enhance the description of the IR flat field in its label.
>> SAM:  Done.  
>> SAM:  Also replaced latest catalog files, tweaked descr of flat in 
         calinfo.txt, and added LBL REV NOTE about resolving Mar 2013 liens.  
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted R.Chen.  See chen_email_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  28 Mar:  Addressed items submitted M.Knight.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.

Result: Certified. [Note: SBN will verify that the wavelength map really does
        show the "smile" prior to public release.] [Additional: This has
        already been verified.]


DIF-C-HRIV/ITS/MRI-5-TEMPEL1-SHAPE-V2.0
=======================================
o  Add definition of "mean radius" to dataset.cat
o  Jian-Yang's presentation page 7 lists a number of typo-type problems in the
   dataset.cat that should be corrected.
o  The Cartesian version (needed by the VRML) appears to be a noticeable
   degradation of the planetocentric version of the shape model.  Tony F. will
   re-create the Cartesian version to improve the translation. The documents
   related to this will need to be corrected to reflect the new derivation in
   the Cartesian version.
o  See Jian-Yang's presentation slides 12-14 contain a laundry list of minor
   documentation corrections and improvements.   
>> SAM:  Partially done: In catalog/hriv.cat, its.cat, mri.cat, directed reader 
         to alternative method developed for Hartley 2 photometry to correct
         for 1/3-pixel "gap", per Jian-Yang's presentation page 13.  Also
         edited dif.cat per Jian-Yang's suggestions of page 13 of his
         presentation.
o  If it's available, Tom Duxbury requested addition information about how the
   shape model was made.

Result: Certification dependent upon internal review and acceptance of new 
        Cartesian version.


DIF-C-HRIV/MRI-5-HARTLEY2-SHAPE-V1.0
====================================
o  Jian-Yang's presentation includes a number of minor documentation issues on
   pages 16, 20.
o  The Cartesian version degradation found in the Tempel 1 model appears here
   as well, and should be similarly corrected and documented.
o  The general liens for the Tempel 1 shape model also apply to this data set.

Recommendation:  SPICE PC kernel parameters don't agree with the dataset.cat
                 description of the axes and rotation.  It probably should.
  
Result:  Certification dependent upon internal review and acceptance of new
         Cartesian version.


EAR-C-COMPIL-4-UNIDENT-V1.0
====================================
o  Need to know things like resolving power of instruments.
o  Would like to know many unidentified lines were observed.
o  It looks like there are values missing from the table that were known to be
   in the papers.   For example, time of observation was recorded in Anita's
   deVico paper.
o  The difference between "line strength" and "brightness" needs to be clearly
   defined, and there should be units associated with both these values.
o  Need a table covering which wavelength were observed for each comet. This
   file would also serve as a useful index of comets included in the data set.
o  The dataset.cat does not look like it was completed prior to submission!

Result: Rejected.  Please edit and re-submit.  SBN will provide guidance.


RO-A-OSINAC/OSIWAC-5-LUTETIA-SHAPE-V1.0
=======================================
o  The dataset.cat has a typo in the radius of the third axis - should be 75,
   not 175 km
o  "plate_shape_definition.asc" refers to the wrong object (Tempel 1, not
   Lutetia).
o  Include additional information about how the model was created (see Tom's
   slide 5).
o  Need a better definition of how "center" is defined/selected.
o  See Jian-Yang's presentation for a short list of minor documentation
   corrections (slide 22).
o  If possible, add quality flags to the facet table.

Result: Certified.


RO-A-OSINAC/OSIWAC-5-STEINS-SHAPE-V1.0
======================================
o  The actual coordinate system is not specified in the dataset.cat.
o  "plate_shape_definition.asc" refers to the wrong object (Tempel 1, not
   Steins).
o  Need a better definition of how "center" is defined/selected.
o  Jian-Yang's presentation slide 24 has a list of minor documentation issues.
o  If possible, add flags to the facet table to indicate which are from direct
   observation and which from lightcurves.

Result: Certified.


DIF-M-HRIV-3/4-EPOXI-MARS-V2.0
DIF-M-MRI-3/4-EPOXI-MARS-V2.0
===============================
o  Typos submitted by email
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  Addressed items submitted R.Chen.  See chen_email_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  Addressed items submitted M.Knight.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  Add Carolyn Crowe has published a paper about this data set to
   to reference list.  Done, 7 Jul.


Result: Certified.


DIF-E-HRIV-3/4-EPOXI-EARTH-V2.0
DIF-E-MRI-3/4-EPOXI-EARTH-V2.0
===============================
o  Add or point to the known geometric information that is "UNK" in the
   labels, from the labels.
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  While trying to figure out exactly what prompted this lien, 
         I discovered the pipeline had stopped computing geometry for the Earth
         *and* Mars data -- it happily computed geometry for the V1.0 archive a few
         years ago.  So for the review the V2.0 VIS Earth and Mars obs were missing
         geometry in their FITS headers which caused the the labels to have geometry
         keywords set to "UNK".  The Science Data Center corrected the problem
         and reprocessed the V2.0 Earth and Mars products, which now have the
         expected geometry FITS headers and PDS labels.
o  Carolyn Crowe has published a paper about this data set which should
   probably be added to the reference list (it's  mentioned in Matthew's typo
   list).
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  Done.
o  Typos submitted by email.
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  Addressed items submitted R.Chen.  See chen_email_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  7 Jul:  Addressed items submitted M.Knight.  See knight_typos_resolved.txt.
>> SAM:  /document/ has outdated ASC doc files. Use ones in DI/EPOXI Doc Set 
   V4.0.  Done, 7 Jul: Copied the ASCII EPOCh Earth Geom docs from Doc Set V4.0.
 
Result: Certified.


The end.